More Components Can Hurt P300 Spellers, Full-Factorial Study Finds
P300 BCI spellers are often built by switching on every component that works on its own, on the assumption that more is better. A preprint study tested that assumption with a four-component full-factorial experiment and found that a component's value is conditional, not additive. Subject calibration was the strongest single contributor; Euclidean Alignment made up for the lack of calibration in zero-calibration settings; and stacking components that are each useful on their own could lower performance, an effect the authors call component anti-synergy. Language model support was not universally beneficial either: its effect depended strongly on how strong the underlying EEG pipeline was.